Having students get things right the first time is what we strive for as teachers.
Yet should it be? Or should it be about the learning process?
John C. Maxwell in his book, 'Failing Forward' illustrates this point quite clearly with a parable about an art lesson and an experiment an art teacher did. It was a pottery class and the teacher divided the class into half, each with a different goal. One half was to be marked on 'Quantity' and the other on 'Quality'. The quality group got an 'A' for making 50lbs worth of pots, a 'B' for 40lbs etc... The other quality group had to make only 1 clay pot but it had to be the best possible pot they could make to get an 'A' grade. At marking time, Maxwell states, an interesting fact emerged. The highest quality pieces came from the 'Quantity' group.
While the quality group were busy thinking about how they were going to make their pots, the quantity group were learning through their mistakes and learning faster. Maxwell then states, 'The only way you can get ahead is to fail early, fail often, and fail forward.'
In my teaching I keep coming back to this parable, especially when I have a student part-way through a project come up to me and ask to restart it. I often ask myself these questions:
How far will this student be able to get in the unit of work when the time comes for me to finish it?
Is this just a waste of resources?
What will this student actually get from restarting the project again?
Then it usually hits me. The student that has just asked me if they can restart their project has actually recognized their mistakes and is asking to correct themselves. They may not exactly know how to correct themselves at this point but they have the courage to give it a try.
Now put yourself in the position of the student. You have just worked up the courage to ask your teacher for more resources to restart your final piece halfway through the unit of work because you know you can do better, what will your teacher say?
What will you say the next time a student asks you to start again?